Yelp vs Google Reviews: Which Matters More for Your Business?
Google and Yelp are two of the most influential places customers leave reviews. Here's how they differ, which deserves more of your attention and how to handle reviews on each.
In this article
If you run a business, you already know how much online reviews matter. Reviews help businesses of all sizes attract customers and win sales, and many people weigh them almost as heavily as a recommendation from a friend.
In this article we look at the differences between Yelp and Google reviews to help you decide where to focus your efforts.
Why Reviews Matter
Before comparing the two platforms, it's worth looking at why reviews are so valuable. There are three main reasons.
Reviews influence local search visibility
Google has said that review count and rating are among the factors that can affect local rankings. Plenty of positive reviews can help your business appear more prominently in local results and on Google Maps, making it easier for potential customers to find you.
Reviews are social proof
Social proof is the idea that people are more likely to make a decision when they see that others have made it before them. Positive reviews show potential customers that your business is reputable and trustworthy.
Reviews are customer feedback
Reviews give you direct, honest feedback from customers. They help you improve your products or services and spot areas for growth. Responding to both positive and negative reviews shows that you value what customers have to say.
What Is Yelp?
Yelp is an online review site that helps people find local businesses. It was founded in 2004 and is especially popular for restaurants, bars, salons, home services and other local businesses.
Yelp's review system
Yelp uses a five-star rating system: customers leave a rating of one to five stars along with a written review. Yelp also runs the "Yelp Elite" program, which recognizes its most active and influential reviewers with special perks.
Yelp uses automated recommendation software that decides which reviews are shown prominently. Reviews it considers less reliable, for example from brand-new or inactive accounts, may be moved to a separate "not currently recommended" section and don't count towards your overall rating.
Yelp advertising
Yelp offers paid options for businesses, including sponsored placements in search results and profile upgrades. These can increase your visibility on Yelp, but paying for ads does not affect your reviews or rating.
Yelp's impact on local businesses
Yelp can have a significant effect on local businesses, especially restaurants and other hospitality businesses. A well-known study by Harvard Business School researcher Michael Luca found that a one-star increase in a restaurant's Yelp rating was associated with a 5–9% increase in revenue.
What Are Google Reviews?
Google reviews are the reviews that appear on a business's Google Business Profile (formerly Google My Business). Because they show up directly in Google Search and on Google Maps, they're often the first reviews a potential customer sees.
Google's review system
Like Yelp, Google uses a five-star rating system with an optional written review. Anyone with a Google account can leave one, and reviews are integrated with Google Maps, so they're visible right where people are looking for local businesses.
Google Business Profile
A Google Business Profile is the listing that appears on Google Maps and in search results. It shows essential information about your business, including your address, phone number, website, opening hours, photos and reviews.
Google advertising
Google offers advertising options for local businesses too, including Google Ads and Local Services Ads. As with Yelp, advertising can increase your visibility, but it has no effect on your reviews.
Yelp vs Google Reviews: Which Is Better for Your Business?
Why Google reviews should be your priority
Google is the dominant search engine, and its reviews appear in front of people at the exact moment they're searching for a business like yours, in Search and in Maps. Leaving a review is also easy for anyone with a Google account. For most businesses, that makes Google reviews the priority.
Why Yelp still matters
Yelp still has a large, loyal user base, particularly for restaurants, hospitality and home services. In those industries, a strong Yelp profile can bring in customers who rely on Yelp's community to choose where to go. Yelp pages also often rank in Google's own search results for business names and local searches.
Key differences
- Audience: Yelp is strongest in hospitality and local services, while Google reviews are used across virtually every industry.
- Community: Yelp is built around an engaged community of reviewers with profiles, followers and Elite status. Google reviews are more utilitarian and tightly integrated with Search and Maps.
- Filtering: Yelp's recommendation software actively filters reviews. Google removes reviews that break its policies but doesn't hide reviews in the same way.
- Asking for reviews: Google allows businesses to ask customers for reviews. Yelp asks businesses not to solicit reviews at all.
How to Get More Reviews (Without Breaking the Rules)
Building a steady stream of reviews takes effort, but it's essential for your online reputation. The key is to follow each platform's rules.
Ask happy customers to review you on Google
It's fine to ask customers to leave a Google review after a positive experience. Make it easy: share your review link by email or text, add it to your website or include a short reminder on receipts. Ask all customers, not only the ones you think will be positive, as selectively asking for good reviews ("review gating") goes against Google's policies.
Don't offer incentives
Both Google and Yelp prohibit offering discounts, gifts or other rewards in exchange for reviews. Incentivized reviews can be removed and may lead to penalties for your listing, so focus on delivering a great experience and making the process easy instead.
Let Yelp reviews come naturally
Yelp discourages businesses from asking for reviews, and solicited reviews are more likely to be filtered out. Instead, claim your free Yelp business page, keep your information up to date, add photos and let customers know you're on Yelp, for example with a "Find us on Yelp" sign, without directly asking them to review you.
The Impact of Positive and Negative Reviews
The power of positive reviews
Positive reviews strengthen your reputation and attract new customers. They reassure people who are comparing you against competitors and can tip a decision in your favor.
The effect of negative reviews
Negative reviews can damage your reputation and turn potential customers away, especially if they go unanswered or point to a recurring problem.
How to handle negative reviews
Respond to negative reviews promptly and professionally. Acknowledge the customer's concerns, apologize for their experience and offer to make it right, ideally by taking the conversation offline. A thoughtful reply shows other readers that you value feedback and are willing to improve.
You can't simply delete reviews you don't like on either platform. If a review breaks the platform's rules, for example if it's fake, offensive or about the wrong business, you can report it for removal. Otherwise, the best response is a constructive reply and better experiences going forward.
Conclusion
Both Yelp and Google reviews matter for local businesses. For most businesses, Google should be the priority: its reviews appear directly in Search and Maps, anyone with a Google account can leave one, and they play a role in local search visibility. Yelp remains important, especially in hospitality and home services, so claim your page and keep it up to date.
Whichever platform your customers prefer, focus on giving people a great experience, follow each platform's review rules and respond to feedback thoughtfully. That's what builds a reputation that brings in new customers.
